Tuesday, August 26, 2025

Capitulation as performative courage in higher education

The Associated Press published a story about my university this past weekend highlighting its many acts of anticipatory obedience and school administrators’ shock that it wasn’t enough to prevent the loss of federal funding. Beyond that, I’m afraid the point of the story escapes me. What is my campus telling us without saying it? Is this a whispered warning to similarly small campuses that capitulation does not protect you from attack? Is it a mea culpa for not demonstrating moral leadership to its students, staff, and community? It is interesting that this story was not picked up by local news outlets; it was only reported by national media AP and ABC News. So, who is the intended audience and what is the message?

I disagree with the writer’s characterization of my campus as apolitical. Education is a foundational institution of democracy and has been under attack since the Reagan Administration. My campus is a prime target of nationally funded local organizations that support the agenda to destroy all democratic institutions clearly laid out in Project 2025. But this project isn’t new. The narrative undermining education, including my campus, has been drip fed for years by the Koch Foundation and Christian Nationalist organizations.   

Charles Koch, owner of Koch Industries, is a key funder of the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), a corporate bill mill, and the State Policy Network (SPN), a network and service organization for the "state-based free market think tank movement," and its stated mission is "to provide strategic assistance to independent research organizations devoted to discovering and developing market-oriented solutions to state and local public policy issues.

Koch Foundation contributions to CU began in 2009 with $23,000 for “educational programs.”  Contributions expanded to include the CU Foundation and the Board of Regents. Contributions to UCCS specifically began in 2013 with a mere $5,000 but hit the six-figure range for the first time in 2016. Then Political Science Department Chair Dunn invited Trump to hold political rallies on UCCS campus twice likely betting on energizing the extremists within a 60-40 gerrymandered red congressional district consisting of the second largest city in Colorado and five military installations. Cat litter queen and QAnon follower Heidi Ganahl was elected to the CU Board of Regents. This was my first year as a grad student in public administration.

By 2017, Koch contributions to CU Boulder and UCCS grew into millions of dollars. I noticed the loss of Local Government courses in my degree program “due to lack of interest.” I guess my interest was irrelevant. The Koch Foundation contributed $1.49 million to CU to establish a right-wing research center. In 2019, the Center for the Study of Government and the Individual, led by Dunn, set to work reinterpreting the version of the founding documents, civics education, and economics that fit the world according to Koch and the rest of the 1%. Their original mission statement thanks to the Wayback Machine: “The Center for the Study of Government and the Individual (CSGI) exists to explore the constitutional, economic, political, and social foundations of a free, flourishing, and prosperous society, and to provide a vehicle for the candid discussion of the proper relationship between government and individuals. Our vision is a citizenry that is equipped for the challenges of self-government ahead of us.” Ominous then, confirmed by the present danger. Thankfully, I managed to graduate in the nick of time in 2018. Finding zero opportunities with local nonprofits I went back for a PhD as COVID got underway.  

In January 2021, following the attempted coup in D.C. my campus inbox started receiving the Koch Bros disinformation rag The Epoch Times indicating their contributions bought access to data and contact lists. I flagged 36 emails between January 18th to March 2nd as spam and reported them to campus IT. I also blocked the emails so I don’t know how long the disinformation was allowed to spread or if it’s ongoing.

I got in trouble in one of my courses for calling out the fact that Reagan’s education department manufactured the education crisis. I was admonished and given a poor grade. Oh well. I think it’s relevant that Dunn taught stats in my program before leading the Koch funded Center. It seems he left a stain. Anyway, I’ll say it again here, Reagan began defunding education and justified it with disinformation (lies) about student learning and teacher qualifications, most of it economic class-based and race-based. Furthermore, Reagan’s campaign gained power alongside what was then called the Christian Right, now Christian Nationalism. Obama shifted control over education to the states in 2015 further opening the door for the extremists. What happens in K-12 doesn’t stay in K-12, it impacts access to higher education.

The alliances that started with Reagan remain active today. Not only are the Koch Bros all over the campus with their anti-democracy reprogramming, but the Christian Nationalists have been very active on campus, too. The center of it seems to be coming from or at least supported by the Woodland Park cult at Charis Bible College. It hosts an annual Truth and Liberty Coalition conference including a weird cross of televangelism and war planning presented by organizations including Turning Point USA whose agenda is to organize protests at the state and national capitol, attack libraries and schools with book bans, and take over school boards. Seriously, you can’t walk from the UCCS library to the parking garage without bumping into a sandwich board announcing a bible study meeting sponsored by Turning Point, or from the library to the student union and not have some fake-friendly middle-aged balding white dude trying to hand you a bible. I know there had been complaints in the past year over dogma-motivated bullying. It’s not a secret on campus that the campus is a target. What is my campus telling us without telling us? Am I facing another nick of time deadline saddled with huge student loan debt and no prospects? Or is it worse? Is Christian Nationalism waiting in the wings to “save” education?

I’ll end with this thought. I never expected to go to college, but I had been told it was the only way out of a life of poverty. Without financial aid I would not have had the opportunity to find my path. Universities are for students to figure out what inspires them, what kind of creativity appeals to them, what life are they meant to lead, and then follow it. How dare anyone limit access to finding your path to the few whose heritage owns the wealth to provide it. The future laid out by the 1% and Christian Nationalism recalls the worst of our past and they are just getting started. If capitulation is all I can expect from my university, I’m scared.

https://apnews.com/article/trump-transgender-diversity-universities-colorado-15388cd568fdd80ce8e70ca321446539